- Newslink Global Insurance Trends
- Insurance Europe and IUA welcome signing of EU/US bilateral agreement regarding (re)insurance
- FCA enters co-operation agreement with Hong Kong Insurance Authority(IA) to support FinTech innovation
- FCA publishes Occasional Paper exploring how aging population would impact financial services
- CMA sets out structure for investigation into investment consultancy services
- Insurance Europe replies to publication of the European Commission’s proposal for the revision of the European supervisory authorities (ESAs) including EIOPA
- ICMIF and AMICE welcome IAIS application paper on the regulation and supervision of mutuals expired
- Hannover Re warns on 2017 targets as earthquakes and hurricanes continue expired
- LMA praises Lloyd's speedy response to recent hurricanes expired
- Post Office Insurance goes live with Duck Creek Policy, Billing, and Rating applications expired
- RSA Canada deploys Guidewire ClaimCentre solution expired
- PartnerRe and RemitRadar to collaborate expired
12th April 2017
EDHEC position paper says there should be a reduction in Solvency II calibration of property investments
In a position paper entitled “The Impact of Solvency II Prudential Regulation on Property Financing in the Insurance Industry”, the Financial Analysis and Accounting Research Centre and the Economics Research Centre at EDHEC Business School conducted a critical analysis of the calibration of property risk under Solvency II prudential regulation.
This study, conducted in partnership with the French Ministry for Housing, tests the robustness of the calculations for two key elements within the Solvency II calibration–the size of the property shock(Value-at-Risk) and the correlation of real estate with other asset classes.
The challenge of this analysis is sizeable given that the European insurance sector currently has E10tr worth of outstanding investments. Real estate has historically played an important role in the asset-liability management (ALM) activities of insurance companies, given its long duration, its contribution to the diversification of portfolio risk, its ability to hedge inflation risk, and its performance. Today, the role of real estate within the ALM activities of insurers must be assessed not only against these traditional indicators, but also in line with the Solvency II regulatory capital requirement.
The 25% capital charge for property investments, required by EIOPA using the British property market as a reference, is highly controversial and often regarded as one of the major obstacles impeding insurers from boosting the real estate share of their portfolios. It restricts the duration matching of assets and liabilities, and also hinders the diversification of assets under management.
“By making use of multiple data sources and complementary methodologies, our study shows that the 25% capital charge imposed on property investments is overestimated. The VaRs calculated in the study are highly variable depending on the geography and the type of property in question(in terms of absolute value, figures are higher for office property and in the UK than they are for residential property and within the euro area), but they are significantly lower than the benchmark level set by Solvency II. In other words, the risk considered is overestimated. Furthermore, it appears that the potential gains from diversification between property and financial assets have been underestimated”, explains Philippe Foulquier, director of the Financial Analysis and Accounting Research Centre at EDHEC Business School.
Given the systematic biases identified within estimations of VaR and of correlation coefficients, this study assesses the overall impact of Solvency II calibration choices on the market risk solvency capital requirement (SCR). A simulation using new estimates results in a significant reduction in capital requirements(between 10% and 20% depending on the share of real estate in the portfolio). This confirms that the current calibrations used by EIOPA are a real obstacle, impeding the return of insurers to the property market.
EDHEC Trends(9 articles)